Industry-leading prices on quality products. Check out what's on sale today!
SHOP NOWClint and Kaia trace how FBI handgun calibers evolved from 9mm to 10mm, then .40 S&W, and back to 9mm. They focus on real shootings, recoil, capacity, and modern ballistic testing.
The video opens with a skit poking fun at changing caliber trends, jumping from 9mm to 10mm and then to .40 caliber. Clint and Kaia then outline the real question: why many law enforcement and federal agencies abandoned .40 S&W and returned to 9mm after widely adopting .40. They note that 9mm was standard, then .40 S&W became popular, and now agencies are moving back to 9mm. Kaia explains that the FBI often sets the standard because it has the resources to conduct extensive research and testing, which smaller agencies can then adopt without repeating the same costly work.
Kaia explains that the shift away from 9mm began with the 1986 FBI Miami shootout involving two bank robbers. Two FBI agents were killed and five wounded. One agent, who later died, hit suspect Michael Platt multiple times with 9mm rounds. Platt was mortally wounded but remained able to fight, killing two agents and injuring others before succumbing. One 9mm round entered through Platt’s arm, traveled into his chest, and stopped about an inch from his heart, leaving roughly 1.3 liters of blood in his lungs. The incident highlighted the lack of immediate incapacitation with the 9mm ammunition used at the time and drove the FBI to seek a more effective handgun cartridge.
In response to Miami, the FBI evaluated 10mm Auto, using a Smith & Wesson 10mm handgun. The 10mm offered more power and better potential for immediate incapacitation, but agents found it impractical for daily carry due to heavy recoil, increased weight, and reduced capacity. The bureau then worked with ammunition manufacturers to develop something more manageable than 10mm yet more effective than the 9mm loads of the 1980s. By shortening the 10mm case and adjusting the load, they arrived at .40 S&W. Clint and Kaia clarify a common misconception: .40 S&W is not a middle ground between 9mm and .45 ACP, but rather between 9mm and 10mm. .40 S&W became the preferred duty round for the FBI and many agencies until about 2014.
Kaia describes the FBI’s Ballistic Research Facility at Quantico, where scientists, not just gun enthusiasts, conduct structured testing. The bureau uses a 500‑point scoring system to evaluate handgun ammunition, including performance after passing through intermediate barriers such as clothing, plywood, drywall, or car doors. Their standard calls for 12 to 18 inches of penetration after such barriers to ensure adequate reach to vital organs from various angles, including shots that must pass through arms, bone, and muscle. When they retested the 9mm ammunition used in the 1986 Miami shootout, it scored only in the 30s out of 500, reflecting very poor performance. That early 9mm was essentially standard full metal jacket and did not meet modern penetration and expansion criteria.
By 2014, ongoing testing showed that modern 9mm duty ammunition could deliver excellent terminal ballistics. The FBI found that specific 9mm loads, such as the Speer Gold Dot G2, provided ideal expansion and velocity, outperforming comparable .40 S&W and .45 ACP duty loads in their standardized tests. Kaia recalls reviewing this data during firearms instructor certification and being surprised that a 9mm load outperformed larger .40 and .45 projectiles. He stresses that this result applies to particular, well‑engineered cartridges, not every 9mm round on the market. Many 9mm loads still lack proper expansion, materials, or loading. The takeaway is that with current technology and reputable manufacturers, selected 9mm duty ammunition can exceed the performance of older .40 and .45 offerings while also offering lower recoil and higher capacity.
The discussion turns to the FBI’s current 9mm duty load, Hornady Critical Duty 135‑grain. Although it is a hollow point, it achieves deep penetration while still expanding reliably. Clint notes that people often assume hollow points penetrate less because the cavity fills with material, expands, and slows the bullet. Kaia explains that advances in design and materials change this behavior. Critical Duty uses a polymer insert, Hornady’s Flex Tip, seated in the hollow cavity. This insert helps prevent soft materials like clothing from prematurely clogging the hollow point and deforming the bullet too early. The round passes through initial barriers before the Flex Tip allows controlled expansion when it encounters denser tissue or bone. This design supports both adequate penetration and effective energy transfer, illustrating how modern 9mm duty ammunition can meet or exceed the FBI’s ballistic standards.
Loading... 
