Industry-leading prices on quality products. Check out what's on sale today!
SHOP NOWTwo Classic Firearms hosts sort various guns, parts, and design features into naughty or nice holiday lists. They compare real-world handling, reliability, ergonomics, and gas management across popular platforms.
The hosts introduce a holiday-themed gun discussion game built around “naughty” and “nice” categories. Sticky notes on the table each hide a firearm, component, or design feature. When a note is flipped, they have about 15 seconds to agree whether the subject belongs on the naughty or nice side, then briefly justify the decision. One side of the table is designated as nice, the other as naughty, with colored markers to keep track. The segment is framed as a more relaxed, discussion-focused video without a specific gun laid out in front of them, and it is separate from their “Outside the Warehouse” content. The hosts emphasize that the criteria are based on their own experiences with reliability, ergonomics, and practical use rather than pure popularity.
The first topic is the SIG Spear NGSW, which both hosts immediately place on the nice list. They note that the NGSW Spear is chambered in .277, also referred to as 6.8x51mm, a hefty and expensive cartridge. One host prefers the .308 version and mentions owning a 13-inch SPR configuration that has been extremely dependable in use, even though it has not been taken into combat. A 16-inch version of the Spear on the table is described as a particularly attractive and enjoyable rifle to shoot. The discussion focuses on the platform’s performance, reliability, and overall shooting experience rather than any military program details, reinforcing why it earns a clear nice rating.
Next, the High Point pistol, specifically the Yeet Cannon, is drawn and quickly labeled naughty, though with some mixed feelings. The hosts acknowledge that High Point handguns are very inexpensive, sometimes around fifty to one hundred dollars, and therefore offer a low-cost way to obtain basic defensive firepower. However, they question the reliability, describing it as almost nothing in some cases. The Yeet Cannon on the table is used as an example of a pistol that technically provides a firearm option for very little money but may not deliver consistent performance. The segment balances the value proposition against concerns about function, leading to a final verdict of naughty despite a few begrudging compliments about affordability.
The roller-delayed operating system is immediately placed on the nice side. The hosts reference classic Heckler & Koch designs such as the MP5 and G3, noting that the roller-delayed mechanism dates back to the 1950s. They explain that the rollers lock into place when the gun is fired, delaying the action from opening and cycling. This delay reduces felt recoil and contributes to the smooth shooting characteristics associated with roller-delayed firearms. One host confirms having shot MP5s and describes them as fantastic, reinforcing the positive reputation of the system. The focus stays on how the mechanical delay improves recoil management and overall shooting comfort, which firmly justifies the nice classification for roller-delayed platforms.
A 45-degree safety selector for AR-15 rifles is drawn and both hosts agree it belongs on the naughty list. They contrast it with the standard 90-degree throw, demonstrating on an NGSW-style rifle how the selector moves from safe to fire. With a 45-degree safety, the lever travels a much shorter distance. One host describes real training experiences where recoil and hand placement caused a knuckle to inadvertently push the selector back toward safe while firing, interrupting strings of fire. He notes that not every 45-degree safety has this issue, as some are slimmer or skeletonized, but the risk of unintentionally engaging the safety remains a concern. The other host adds that a full 90-degree throw provides clearer tactile confirmation of safe versus fire. They mention telling HK that future A10 iterations should retain a 90-degree throw, underscoring their preference and the naughty verdict for 45-degree selectors.
Bullpup rifles are debated and ultimately placed on the nice list, though with caveats. The hosts show a bullpup chambered in .308 with a 16-inch barrel, pointing out that the overall length is comparable to an 11-inch AR-15 SBR while still maintaining full rifle barrel length. This compactness is praised for maneuverability and for avoiding National Firearms Act issues while retaining ballistic performance. However, they criticize bullpups for being bulky and heavy, and for having a different manual of arms that can be less intuitive. One host notes that left-handed shooters may end up closer to the ejection port, depending on the ejection pattern, and could experience more gas and debris. Using the Springfield Hellion as an example, they describe how the muzzle blast and action are closer to the shooter’s face. Despite these drawbacks, the ability to keep a rifle-length barrel in a short package keeps bullpups on the nice side, albeit with some naughty aspects.
The Radian SD charging handle is selected and judged naughty. The hosts recall a previous gas-busting charging handle comparison where multiple brands were tested. The Radian SD design uses holes in the charging handle, with the claim that gas would vent through them. One host questions this, pointing out that the charging handle sits inside the upper receiver against the walls, leaving nowhere practical for gas to escape. In testing, gas still blew back into their faces, and the handle did not reduce gas as expected, leading to disappointment despite their overall respect for Radian as a company. The topic then shifts to reciprocating charging handles, especially on rifles like the AK and SCAR 17. The hosts describe scenarios where unconventional grips or shooting from compromised positions allow a thumb or hand to contact the moving handle, causing discomfort and inducing malfunctions. They argue that a non-reciprocating charging handle removes this failure point, and while acknowledging the proven reliability of AKs, they still classify reciprocating handles as naughty from an ergonomics and reliability standpoint.
The hosts briefly address James Reeves, jokingly placing him on the naughty list for superficial reasons like appearance, then move on to KelTec. Despite some criticism in the broader community, they agree KelTec belongs on the nice list, noting that the company continues to produce decent, innovative firearms at reasonable prices. Innovation is highlighted as a key reason for the positive rating. When the AK platform appears, one host initially questions whether its reciprocating charging handle issues should make it naughty, but they ultimately agree the AK is nice overall. They emphasize that AK-47 rifles are reliable and proven, even if certain design elements, such as the reciprocating handle and weight on some tactical configurations, are less than ideal. An example AK set up with AR-style features is mentioned as heavy, reinforcing their view that AR-15s can be superior in ergonomics. Still, the AK’s track record and function secure it a place on the nice list despite its naughty components.
Loading... 
