levels.svg levels icon sort-down.svg sort down icon sort-up.svg sort up icon search.svg search icon user-circle.svg user circle icon cart-alt.svg cart icon plus.svg plus icon chevron-left.svg chevron left icon chevron-right.svg chevron right icon phone.svg phone icon zoom-in.svg zoom in icon
HomeVideosGun AccessoriesShould You Use A Suppressor For Home Defense?

Should You Use A Suppressor For Home Defense?

· June 14th, 2023 · Gun Accessories

Clint examines whether running a suppressor on a home defense gun makes practical sense. He weighs sound, communication, legal concerns, and intruder response.

Video Summary

Read the full transcript

Intro: What Makes an Ideal Home Defense Gun?

The video opens with several different rifles being presented as the “ideal” home defense gun before pointing out what they all share: a suppressor. Clint frames the discussion around whether a silencer on a home defense firearm is actually a good idea. He notes that this has been debated for a while, especially after John Lovell of Warrior Poet Society argued against using suppressors on home defense guns. Clint acknowledges Lovell’s points but aligns more with MrGunsnGear in politely disagreeing. He emphasizes that the choice is personal and tied to whether someone wants to rely on an NFA-regulated item for home defense. From the outset, he defines a suppressor or silencer as a device that reduces both sound and muzzle flash when a firearm is discharged indoors at close range.

Why Consider a Suppressor Indoors?

Clint explains that most home defense shootings will occur inside a house, apartment, or other enclosed structure, where gunfire is extremely loud and concussive. He compares it to shooting unsuppressed firearms at an indoor range, especially short AR-15s with muzzle brakes, which can be disorienting and intimidating. A suppressor, he argues, can significantly reduce that blast and flash, making it less punishing on the shooter and everyone else in the room. He notes that in a real defensive incident, there is unlikely to be time or presence of mind to put on hearing protection or even remember to turn on an optic. When people hear a bump in the night, they often rationalize it as something benign, and by the time they realize it is a real threat, events are unfolding too quickly for extra steps.

Clint’s Suppressed 300 Blackout Setup

To ground the discussion, Clint describes his own home defense rifle. It is a Mark18-style setup with an SBR lower, using a Daniel Defense lower receiver and an Aero Precision M4 Enhanced upper receiver. The gun is chambered in 300 Blackout with an 8-inch barrel. On the muzzle he runs the HuxWrx Flow 762 Ti suppressor. He notes that this configuration has been reliable and satisfying for him and that he considers it close to an ideal home defense platform. He stresses that firing this rifle indoors without a suppressor would be extremely unpleasant, especially without hearing protection, which is the most realistic scenario in a sudden home invasion. For him, the suppressor is about gaining an advantage in a confined environment rather than comfort alone.

Hearing Loss, Family Safety, and Communication

Clint addresses the common argument that suppressors are primarily about preventing hearing loss in a defensive shooting. He concedes that even if some hearing damage occurs, survival is the priority. However, he brings up accounts he has read where the defender reportedly suffered little long-term hearing loss due to adrenaline and auditory exclusion, while family members elsewhere in the house experienced tinnitus and temporary hearing issues for months. He cannot verify every detail of those stories but sees them as plausible. This leads into a broader point: a suppressor can help protect loved ones’ hearing and improve communication during a chaotic incident. He notes that the Marine Corps has moved toward issuing suppressors to riflemen because reduced blast makes it easier to communicate and manage the “fog of war,” even though suppressed guns are still far from silent, especially with supersonic ammunition and semi-automatic actions.

Noise, Neighbors, and Alerting 911

Clint then revisits one of John Lovell’s concerns: in dense environments like apartment buildings, loud, unsuppressed gunfire can serve as an alarm to neighbors. If an intruder kicks in a door and the defender has no time to call 911, the first shots may be the only signal others receive that something is wrong. In theory, that noise could prompt neighbors to call the police. He acknowledges that this assumes people are paying attention and not distracted by phones or headphones, which is not always realistic. Still, he recognizes that running unsuppressed may increase the chance that someone nearby realizes a violent event is occurring and contacts authorities. This is one of the tradeoffs he weighs against the benefits of reduced blast and better communication inside the home when using a suppressor.

Legal Concerns with NFA Items in Self-Defense

Another major topic is the legal risk of using NFA-regulated items such as short-barreled rifles and suppressors in a defensive shooting. Clint notes that his Mark18-style rifle combines two NFA items: the SBR configuration and the silencer. He suggests that a prosecutor could portray this as evidence of excessive intent, arguing that he went beyond what was necessary to stop a threat. He references 18 U.S. Code 924 and encourages viewers to read it, pointing out that there are specific stipulations involving NFA items in certain criminal contexts, which he finds concerning. He acknowledges that this legal angle is unsettling but states that it does not deter him from choosing this setup for home defense. For him, the tactical advantages of the configuration outweigh the potential for a prosecutor to frame it negatively.

Psychological Impact on Multiple Intruders

Clint also discusses the psychological effect of gunfire on intruders, especially when there are multiple offenders. Drawing from videos often shared by MrGunsnGear, he notes that in many home invasion clips, once the homeowner fires several shots, the intruders immediately scatter and flee. He characterizes many of these criminals as cowards who are not prepared to face armed resistance. Loud, unsuppressed gunfire from an AR or even a handgun can send a clear message that the homeowner is a capable threat, which can end the encounter quickly. He then questions whether a suppressed firearm would have the same deterrent effect. Based on his experience shooting indoors, he believes suppressed fire is still startling and uncomfortable on the receiving end, even if less concussive than unsuppressed, and would likely still create a strong psychological shock for intruders.

Enter Our Current Giveaway

Enter the Classic Firearms giveaway to win the Sons of Liberty MK1 Rifle Package

 
  Loading...