Industry-leading prices on quality products. Check out what's on sale today!
SHOP NOWClassic Firearms hosts debate their top five striker-fired pistols, comparing features, ergonomics, and roles. They highlight concealed carry options, competition setups, and notable triggers.
The video opens with a quick back-and-forth about choosing a striker-fired pistol, name-dropping models like the HK VP9L, FN 509, Canik Mete SFX, Springfield Hellcat, and Taurus G3C. The hosts, Jason and Eliza, introduce a “Top 5 Fight” focused specifically on striker-fired pistols. Each has created a separate list without seeing the other’s picks. They invite viewers to decide which list is better and to comment with their own choices and any pistols they think were overlooked. The tone is light and competitive, but the focus is on comparing real-world performance, reliability, and how each handgun fits different roles such as concealed carry or range use.
At number five, Eliza selects the SIG Macro. She emphasizes SIG reliability and notes that she carries a Macro for concealed carry. The pistol offers a 17+1 round capacity, can be configured with or without a compensator, and is optic ready. She mentions front slide serrations, grip texture, and a high beavertail that aids control, while hinting that the serrations could be more pronounced. Jason counters with the Smith & Wesson M&P 2.0 as his number five. He highlights the updated trigger, strong ergonomics, and very aggressive grip stippling. The model shown is not optic ready, but he notes that optic-ready versions exist. Capacity is also 17+1, and he prefers the original polymer version over the metal variant for his own shooting.
Before the number four picks, there is a sponsor segment about CCW Safe, focusing on legal support and critical response after a defensive incident. Returning to the list, Jason’s number four is the CZ P-10 F Comp. He explains that “Comp” in this case means competition model, not a compensated slide, and notes CZ’s unusual naming. He describes the pistol as cost-effective with excellent ergonomics, a flat-faced trigger with a crisp 90-degree break, strong grip texture, generous capacity, and an optics-ready slide. He also points out the gold finish option. Eliza’s number four is the Smith & Wesson M&P 9 M2.0 with an aluminum frame. Her version is ported, which she says can help some shooters, and it is optic ready. It retains the aggressive stippling and 17+1 capacity, but she cautions that the texture can be abrasive for inside-the-waistband carry without an undershirt.
For the number three slot, the hosts’ lists begin to overlap. Eliza chooses the CZ P-10 F Comp that Jason previously discussed. She reiterates that it is a phenomenal shooter with a strong trigger and notes her preference for the black-and-gold aesthetic, which matches her personal style. Jason’s number three is the SIG P365 Macro, which ranks higher on his list than on hers. He views it as an excellent concealed carry option that still works well for larger hands, allowing a full grip. The pistol is optics ready and supports higher-capacity magazines, including SIG “Fuse” magazines that can provide 21 rounds in a compact package. He praises the trigger and mentions that the P365 line remains one of the most popular handgun families in the United States.
At number two, Jason selects a Walther PDP F-series pistol. He notes that it was marketed toward women but finds that it fits his hands extremely well. The model shown has a 4-inch barrel and a size comparable to a Glock 19. Features include an optics-ready slide, a pronounced magwell, extended magazines, and Walther’s well-regarded “Pro” trigger with a clean break and short reset. He demonstrates the trigger characteristics and praises its feel. Eliza’s number two is a Walther steel frame Pro model. Her pistol does not have the flared magwell, but she values the added weight of the steel frame for control, especially in a competition-style role. She mentions that the Pro variant includes an upgraded Pro X trigger and is optic ready. She prefers the rear palm swell and grip contour on this model over the PDP F, finding it more comfortable despite the F-series being marketed toward female shooters.
Before revealing their top picks, the hosts share honorable mentions. Eliza chooses the Glock 17, referencing the Gen 5 version. She acknowledges that the grip size is not her favorite but still respects the platform for its reliability and consistent trigger. She notes that Glock has made incremental changes over generations and jokingly suggests that “perfection” might arrive with a sixth generation. Jason’s honorable mention is the Walther Q5 Match. He describes it as a 5-inch, metal-framed pistol with generous slide cuts, an optics-ready system, and a highly regarded trigger. He considers it extremely accurate and notes its substantial weight and build quality. The pistol features a pronounced beavertail and a distinctive blue trigger shoe. Both hosts agree that Walther’s overall craftsmanship and attention to detail stand out in this model.
For the number one position, Eliza selects the Glock 19. She anticipates criticism about favoring Glock but clarifies that her preference is based on long-term use rather than sponsorship. The Glock 19 was one of the first pistols she used when entering the industry, and she associates it with both familiarity and dependable performance. She distinguishes it from the Glock 17, which she placed as an honorable mention due to grip size. The Glock 19’s more compact frame suits her hands better while still offering the capacity and reliability that the platform is known for. She credits the pistol’s track record and her own experience with it as the reasons it tops her striker-fired list.
Loading... 
