The video opens with two Classic Firearms hosts setting up a head-to-head “top five competition pistols” battle and inviting viewers to decide whose list wins. Kenzie is introduced as the newest team member and an experienced competitive shooter with a broad background that includes GSSF, Steel Challenge, USPSA, 2-gun, 3-gun, .22 PRS, and AK matches. She explains GSSF as Glock Shooting Sports Foundation, a Glock-only match series where she spent years running different Glock models, even a Glock 43 in the subcompact division. For her number five pick, she chooses the Glock 17 Gen 2, calling it her first competition pistol and a great entry-level choice. The discussion emphasizes that new competitors should start with whatever reliable stock handgun they already own. The co-host highlights Glock simplicity and reliability, contrasting the older Gen 2 trade-in style guns with modern Gen 5 models that offer updated ergonomics and features while still being straightforward, durable match workhorses.
The conversation moves from the older Glock 17 Gen 2 toward more modern competition platforms. A brief comparison is made between law-enforcement trade-in style pistols and newer Gen 5 Glocks, underscoring how incremental improvements can matter in matches. The hosts then debate the SIG Sauer X5 as a number five pick, focusing on its built-in compensator, external 1911-style safety, and hammer-fired system. They note that the external safety divides opinions in competition, with some shooters loving the familiar 1911-style controls and others preferring simpler striker-fired setups. Attention shifts to the Canik SFx Rival and Rival S, with particular praise for the Rival S’s heavier construction that tames recoil and keeps the sights flatter. The Canik’s ergonomics, ambidextrous controls, generous magazine capacity, and extensive out-of-the-box package—optic plates, fiber optic sights, and interchangeable mag releases—are highlighted as making it immediately competition-ready. One host argues the Rival S deserves a higher ranking based on extensive match use.
The hosts introduce the Walther Q5 Match Steel Frame, describing it as an evolution of the original polymer Q5 into a serious metal-framed competition pistol. The steel frame is credited with significantly improving recoil control and shot-to-shot recovery, while the factory competition trigger and comfortable ergonomics make it easy to shoot well at speed. High-capacity magazines make it suitable for USPSA and 3-gun divisions, and aftermarket grip options allow shooters to fine-tune fit and texture. They emphasize that Walther “nailed” the Q5 Match, praising its optics-ready slide and adjustable iron sights that let competitors choose between red dots and refined irons. The hosts reference a recent trip to the IWA show in Nuremberg, Germany, where they interviewed Walther personnel and trainers, calling Walther one of the most underrated handgun brands in the United States. They tease that another Walther model later in the list may shoot even better than the Q5 Match, building anticipation for a future segment.
Focus shifts to the Smith & Wesson M&P 2.0 as a strong competition choice with deep brand history. The hosts point out its 17-round capacity, optics-ready configuration, and ergonomics that many shooters find more natural than some competitors. Affordability is a major selling point, making it accessible for new competitors. They mention GM-level shooter Hunter Constantine, who runs the M&P 2.0 either completely stock or with an Apex trigger and extended base pads for competition. This leads into a broader discussion about modifying pistols for matches versus keeping carry guns stock. Competition guns often receive upgraded triggers, stippling, and extended base pads to improve performance, but the hosts caution that defensive carry pistols should remain unmodified to avoid added failure points, potential warranty issues, and legal or reliability concerns. One host notes carrying an M&P 2.0 for six years, citing its reliability as proof that a relatively simple, well-made polymer pistol can serve both defensive and competitive roles when configured appropriately.
The hosts briefly highlight an affordable polymer competition pistol that looks ordinary but reportedly shoots far better than its appearance suggests, surprising one of them with its performance and value. The video then cuts to a sponsored segment from American Hartford Gold, explaining how some shooters diversify their investments with precious metals like gold, silver, and platinum. The sponsor’s A+ Better Business Bureau rating, strong online reviews, and buyback-focused customer service model are mentioned to reassure potential customers. After the ad, the discussion returns to firearms with the introduction of the CZ Shadow 2. The Shadow 2 is described as a true out-of-the-box competition pistol featuring a double-action/single-action trigger system. The hosts explain USPSA-style rules that require DA/SA pistols to start in double action, walking through the process of safely lowering the hammer before the start signal. They note the heavy initial double-action pull and how it affects the first shot, while acknowledging that many shooters later modify Shadow 2 triggers and hammer springs to improve performance and reduce the risk of accidental discharges during decocking.
Continuing with the CZ Shadow 2, the hosts emphasize its popularity as a heavy metal competition pistol that dominates many USPSA and IPSC divisions. They predict that an unmodified double-action first shot will often impact low due to the heavy pull weight, which is why many competitors install lighter hammer springs and refined trigger components. This tuning transforms the Shadow 2 into a smoother, more predictable DA/SA platform while still meeting safety rules. The conversation then transitions to the Walther PDP Match Steel Frame, praised for its steel frame, flat-face trigger, improved sights, and optics-ready slide. The hosts highlight the PDP Match’s exceptionally good trigger feel, low recoil, and minimal dot movement, which help shooters track their sights through fast strings. They note that heavier steel-framed guns like the PDP Match and Shadow 2 are becoming the norm in competition because their extra mass improves shootability and controllability. The Canik Rival S steel frame is introduced with added lock grips, a flared magwell, ambidextrous slide stops, and thumb rests, reinforcing the trend toward heavy, feature-rich match pistols.
The Canik Rival S steel-frame pistol receives more detailed attention, with the hosts noting its interchangeable fiber optic front sights and strong out-of-the-box performance. Compared to the polymer Rival, the steel-frame version offers reduced felt recoil and excellent return to zero, making it easier to keep the dot or sights stable during rapid fire. The discussion shifts to a Sig X5 equipped with an accelerated thumb rest, raising concerns about holster compatibility and whether such a rest is truly necessary for 9mm competition guns versus major power factor calibers. They mention that the thumb rest’s placement and angle can create ergonomic issues for many shooters. Taran Tactical base pads for the Canik are highlighted for boosting magazine capacity, forming part of a straightforward competition setup that also includes an SRO optic, flared magwell, and stock competition trigger. The hosts then present honorable mentions: a Taran Tactical Combat Master Glock 34 with a Timney Alpha trigger, optic cut, ported slide, and match-grade barrel, and the HK VP9 Long Slide, praised for its optics-ready, ported long slide that helps manage recoil on a polymer platform.
The HK VP9 Long Slide is discussed in more depth, with the hosts noting its ported, optics-ready long slide, polymer frame, and high-capacity magazines that hold around 20 rounds. They comment that despite the ports, the gun still feels slightly snappy in recoil compared to heavier steel-framed competitors. This leads into a comparison between HK’s paddle-style magazine release and the more common button release. One shooter demonstrates using a middle finger to activate the paddle due to limited thumb reach, suggesting that with proper training this method can actually be faster than a traditional button. However, they acknowledge that the paddle system may confuse new shooters who are accustomed to button releases. The segment underscores how control layouts and manual of arms can influence competition performance and learning curves, even when the base pistol has strong accuracy and capacity. The VP9 Long Slide is positioned as a capable, optics-ready polymer option that rewards dedicated practice with its unique controls.
Attention turns to the Nighthawk BDS9, described as a handmade, double-stack 1911-style competition pistol from Nighthawk’s “boardroom” series. Each pistol is built start-to-finish by a single gunsmith, representing a high-end step in a shooter’s progression from basic polymer platforms to premium race guns. The hosts outline custom competition-oriented modifications applied to this BDS9, including adding an ambidextrous safety for better control during transitions, a magwell to speed reloads, and a refined trigger job to maximize precision and consistency. Taran Tactical base pads are used to push capacity to roughly 27–28 rounds, ideal for USPSA and 3-gun stages with minimal reloads. A Holosun 507 Comp optic is mounted, configured with a small central dot plus a 20 MOA circle reticle. This setup is tailored for both precise 30–50 yard shots and fast, close-range target engagement, giving the shooter flexibility across diverse match stages while leveraging the 1911-style ergonomics and crisp trigger.
The hosts expand on the magazine setup, explaining how extended Taran Tactical base pads combined with a specialized competition follower add roughly one extra round of capacity, reaching around 27–29 rounds. The trade-off is that the slide no longer locks back on empty, a compromise many competitors accept for higher capacity. They revisit the Nighthawk pistol’s extremely tight slide-to-frame tolerances and handmade construction, noting its aggressive yet manageable factory grip texture that remains secure in wet or sweaty conditions. The approximate price is around $6,000 before adding an optic, underscoring its status as a premium race gun. The pistol can switch between handmade iron sights and an optic plate with an RMR footprint, and this build uses a large Dawson Ice magwell instead of a TTI magwell for faster reload funnels. The video closes by introducing the speaker’s number one competition pistol choice, using a G34 Combat Master from Taran Tactical Innovations as a stand-in while hinting that the actual top pick is a Taran Tactical model such as the Pit Viper, with a stated personal preference for iron sights despite acknowledging the performance advantages of red dots.
Loading...