The hosts open their SHOT Show 2024 coverage by explaining that days of range time and booth visits are being distilled into a focused series of top five videos, starting with pistols. They introduce the ranking format and immediately dive into their number five pick, the Daniel Defense H9. The H9 earns a spot largely on Daniel Defense’s reputation for quality and expected reliability, but the panel is blunt that this striker-fired pistol feels like a rebranded, previously seen design rather than a groundbreaking new handgun. It is described as competent yet average, with limited innovation compared to the competition. Moving to the number four slot, they highlight the Shadow Systems XRP/MRP, essentially an XR920 variant with a dramatically shortened compensator that keeps overall length within a Glock 17 footprint. The compensator uses a tri-lug style barrel attachment and is sold as a complete package. The hosts praise Shadow Systems’ ergonomics and trigger, calling them clear upgrades over standard Glock offerings while retaining duty-ready reliability.
The discussion continues with more detail on Shadow Systems and how extensively the company reworks Glock-style pistols. The hosts describe significant trigger improvements, slide machining, and a shortened compensator that tucks in close to the frame in an Afterburner-style configuration, making the guns feel distinctly non-Glock in hand and on the range. Reliability is emphasized as being on par with factory duty pistols despite the custom-feeling features. The countdown then shifts to the number three pistol, the Canik TTI Combat. The panel expects this model to be extremely popular and acknowledges it as an excellent shooter, but they criticize it for limited innovation. One commentator, a strong admirer of Taran Tactical Innovations, notes that the Canik TTI Combat mainly adds a small compensator, TTI branding, and color changes. This is contrasted with the heavily customized Glock 34 Combat Master, which features full-frame stippling, a substantially reworked trigger, and an island slide cut. They attribute the restrained approach to a marketing and pricing strategy aimed at keeping the pistol around $999 instead of pushing into a $1499 premium tier, and speculate about a future steel-frame, fully upgraded Combat Master-style Canik.
The hosts broaden the conversation by praising Canik’s strong aftermarket support and savvy marketing, noting that many imported, especially Turkish, handguns lack this level of ecosystem and brand-building. They highlight the value of the TTI collaboration in raising Canik’s profile. The countdown moves to the number two slot, where the panel debates several Beretta options. The Beretta APX Compact Tactical and its full-size counterpart are considered for their tactical features, while the competition-focused Beretta 92XI Squalo is praised for its refined trigger and match-oriented setup. Another contender is the tiny .32 ACP Beretta Tomcat with its distinctive tip-up barrel, which the hosts enjoyed shooting suppressed. However, they report that shooters with large hands experienced slide bite and malfunctions due to the extremely small frame, whereas those with smaller hands had a better experience. Overall, Beretta is described as performing very well across its lineup. The hosts also mention the return of the PX4 Storm with its rotating barrel as an honorable mention and prepare to transition into a broader round of individual honorable mentions.
The honorable mentions segment begins with each host naming a standout pistol that did not quite make the top five list. One mentions a Glock 19X variant equipped with a threaded barrel and optic cut, effectively modernizing a proven crossover platform for suppressor and red dot use. Another highlight is the CAR X9, a subcompact double-stack pistol that is optic-ready and notable for its magazine compatibility with CAR, Sig P365, and Springfield Hellcat magazines, giving users flexible options for capacity and sourcing spares. The CZ Shadow Compact is also praised, particularly for its transferable lifetime warranty that even includes free barrel replacement, underscoring CZ’s confidence in durability and long-term support. The new Glock 49 is referenced as a noteworthy but not revolutionary addition, offering incremental evolution rather than a radical redesign. These honorable mentions collectively showcase trends toward optics-ready slides, threaded barrels, cross-platform magazine compatibility, and strong manufacturer-backed warranties that appeal to both enthusiasts and practical users.
The number one spot goes to the Walther PDP steel frame, which the hosts describe as a standout pistol purpose-built for red dot shooters. Its grip angle is tuned so that the dot naturally appears in the shooter’s sight picture, and the trigger is highlighted as very crisp and controllable. Ergonomics are repeatedly praised, with the panel suggesting that Walther’s main challenge in the U.S. market is marketing, not product quality. They note that the broader PDP line offers multiple configurations, and this steel-frame version blends match-gun performance with duty-gun robustness. The design aims to capture the best aspects of competition pistols—such as shootability and trigger refinement—while maintaining the reliability and safety expected of a service handgun, addressing concerns that pure match guns can be finicky or less safe for hard use. The video closes by inviting viewers to comment with their favorite handguns from the SHOT Show coverage and teasing upcoming top-five lists for accessories, long guns, bolt guns, PCCs, and PDWs based on what they saw at the event.
Loading...